Menu

WHITE-COLLAR CRIME: INVESTIGATING COMPANY MISCONDUCT

Publications, Research paper

ABSTRACT

White-collar crime is a non-violent crime in which the number one reason is typically economic in nature. White-collar criminals usually occup an expert position of strength and/or status, and one which command nicely above common repayment. This research paper delves into the complex realm of white-collar crime and corporate misconduct, shedding mild on the clandestine activities that frequently arise within the confines of boardrooms and govt suits. White-collar crime, generally associated with individuals in positions of power and impact, encompasses a range of illegal activities, which includes fraud, embezzlement, insider buying and selling, and bribery. This examine seeks to provide a top-level view of the various facets of white-collar crime and corporate misconduct, exploring their causes, results, and regulatory responses. Drawing on theoretical frameworks and empirical proof, it examines the mental, social, and economic factors that make contributions to the perpetration of such offences, in addition to the challenges related to detecting and prosecuting them. By using synthesizing current literature and providing important insights, it objectives to beautify know-how of white-collar crime and corporate misconduct, thereby informing policymakers, practitioners, and students in their efforts to combat financial malfeasance and promote integrity inside the corporate world.

KEYWORDS: White-Collar Crimes, Fraud, Corruption, Economic System, Society

INTRODUCTION

White collar crime, a term first coined in 1939, refers to non-violent offenses committed by individuals or agencies within the route in their commercial enterprise activities. White-collar crime refers to non-violent crimes that are committed by individuals, generally in the route of their professional work, and are stimulated via economic gain. White-collar crimes commonly contain deception, fraud, or other unethical practices which can be supposed to mislead or defraud individuals, corporations, or the government. a few examples of white-collar crimes consist of insider trading, embezzlement, money laundering, Ponzi schemes, and cybercrime. White-collar crimes regularly bring about vast financial losses for people and companies and may have some distance-achieving outcomes for the financial system and society as a whole. 

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This paper is of descriptive nature and the research is based on secondary sources for the deep analysis of corporate fraud and white-collar crime in India. Secondary sources of facts like newspapers, journals, case studies and web sites are used for studies.

REVIEW OF LITERATURE

The history of white-collar crime is rich and lengthy, spanning several centuries. However, sociologist Edwin Sutherland did not create the term “white-collar crime” until the early 20th century. Sutherland was intrigued by the crimes that people of respectable social standing committed, which frequently remained unreported and unpunished. Because they involved people in positions of trust and influence, he contended that these crimes were every bit as destructive as traditional ones, if not more so. Following Sutherland’s study, there was an increasing awareness of the gravity and frequency of white-collar crime. As a result, a number of laws and regulations were enacted to reduce white-collar crime, such as the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act of 1977 and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 in the United States. Even with these attempts, white-collar crime remains a prominent issue, both in the United States and globally. Advancements in technology and globalization have made it easier for individuals to commit crimes, while at the same time posing challenges for law enforcement in detecting and prosecuting these offenses.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES

White-collar crimes may have substantial and a far-reaching effect on people, businesses, and society as a whole. The economic losses because of those crimes can be astounding, and they are able to undermine public believe in establishments and government. right here are some of the key ways wherein white-collar crimes will have an impact:

1. Financial Losses

2. Economic effect

3. Social impact

4. Environmental effect

KINDS OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES

White collar crimes encompass a extensive spectrum of offenses, every with its particular characteristics, strategies, and affects. a number of the most commonplace kinds consist of: 

  • Fraud
  • Embezzlement
  • Insider trading
  • Bribery and Corruption 
  • Money Laundering
  • Tax Evasion
  • Intellectual Property Theft
  • Cybercrimes
  • Corporate Espionage

CAUSE AT THE BACK OF COMMITTING WHITE COLLAR CRIME

There are numerous motives in the behind committing white collar crime. The reasons are said below: 

1. Lack of Awareness: In many instances it’s far seen that victims fails to apprehend and are effortlessly fooled at the arms of such perpetrators.

2. Greed: The ever-increasing desires of man is one of the only element at the back of the commission of such offenses. 

3. Convincing Power of the Perpetrators: The perpetrator can without difficulty persuade the victim as they do not contain violent streaks that characterize traditional crimes. 

6. Lack of Proper Implementation of Law: Incapability to execute existing legal guidelines in a strict way frequently results in upward thrust of such acts. 

7. Development of Technology: Benefit of technologies is any other cause at the back of rapid boom of white-collar crime. Internet is every other contributing component for increase of this sort of crime. 

WHITE-COLLAR CRIME IN INDIA: WHY IS THERE AN INCREASE IN WHITE COLLAR CRIMES IN INDIA?

India has a very obvious least expensive divide among its social training, wealthy and bad. there is a massive chew of population that is uneducated and is underneath poverty line that reasons lack of know-how and being more liable to white-collar crimes.  Some of the various motives augmenting the boom of white-collar crimes in India are defined below:

  1. Lack of Strict laws: Although India already has laws towards financial fraudulence, these want to be made more stringent to penalize offenders. Perpetrators tend to take advantage of loopholes in the present legal guidelines and getaway successfully.
  2. Greed: It is believed that there may be greed in-built inside the nature of man. It states authentic within the instances of white-collar crimes as those are broadly speaking devoted by using humans already part of high society circles with a lot wealth that already cannot be accounted for.
  3. Lack Of Understanding Among General Population: those who fall prey to white-collar crimes frequently fail to make sense of the character of the crime that has been committed and are unaware of the approaches to be accompanied with a purpose to register a complaint towards such offence. 
  4. Modern Technology: White-caller crimes has reached a much wider target audience with the help of internet and technology. 

The purpose for such fast growth in white collar crime in current many years is frequently attributed to the quick developing economy and business boom. The Santhanam Committee report drew a lucid image of white-collar crimes dedicated by means of human beings belonging to higher social status. It consists of businessmen, industrialists, contractors, suppliers and not notably corrupt public officials. moreover, latest traits in era, specially in the final years of the twentieth century, have opened up new dimensions for deviants to further white-collar crimes. in step with the converting dynamics of white-collar crime in India, The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has discovered a total of 6,533 cases of corruption over the past 10 years, of which 517 cases have been recorded during the last years. within the mild of such extraordinary numbers, it’s miles safe to mention India is properly in the grip of White-collar Crimes. A new type of white-collar crimes, typically referred to as cyber-crimes, has exponentially multiplied. Such crimes have become a worldwide issue for law enforcement agencies.

THE COST OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES 

The financial impact of white-collar crimes is magnificent, often leading to billions of greenbacks in losses for agencies, investors, and customers. however, the non-monetary effects can be similarly unfavourable. White collar crimes erode trust in establishments, undermine the integrity of the market, and may lead to widespread reputational harm for the groups concerned. The social value of those crimes, in terms of lost jobs, reduced customer self-belief, and typical monetary instability, is likewise extensive. 

MONETARY EFFECT OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES ON AGENCIES, TRADERS, AND CUSTOMERS 

White-collar crimes will have a giant economic effect on agencies, buyers, and customers. The monetary losses because of these crimes may be outstanding, and they could undermine public consider in institutions and authorities. right here are some of the key methods wherein white-collar crimes may have a financial effect:

  1. Commercial enterprise Losses: White-collar crimes can result in massive financial losses for organizations.
  2. Investor confidence: Insider buying and selling and other forms of securities fraud can undermine the integrity of the monetary markets, leading investors to lose confidence within the gadget.
  3. Purchaser effect: pyramid schemes and different forms of investment fraud can result in individuals losing their life savings or retirement price range. 
  4. Fee of regulation: Governments may additionally want to make investments substantial resources so as to analyze and prosecute white-collar crimes, which can be a drain on public funds. Generally, the monetary effect of white-collar crimes may be some distance-reaching and may have significant consequences for businesses, investors, and consumers. it’s miles vital for individuals, companies, and authorities’ businesses to take steps to prevent and address those crimes to be able to protect the economic system and society as an entire.

NON-ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES

The effect of white-collar crimes isn’t always constrained to monetary losses and economic harm. these crimes also can have substantial non-economic outcomes, especially in phrases of damage to popularity and lack of consider. here are some of the key methods in which white-collar crimes will have non-monetary results: 

  1. Loss of Trust: White-collar crimes can erode public trust with in establishments and                     government. individuals might also become much less trusting of commercial enterprise leaders, government officers, and others in positions of authority.
  2. Reputational harm: White-collar crimes can motive widespread reputational harm to people and organizations. as soon as a white-collar crime has been devoted, it may be tough for people and groups to regain the consider of their stakeholders and customers. 
  3. Legal Sanctions: White-collar criminals may additionally face prison sanctions, inclusive of fines, imprisonment, or network carrier. those sanctions could have a vast impact on a person’s lifestyles and reputation. 
  4. Non-public Relationships: White-collar crimes can stress personal relationships, mainly with family participants and near ones. people may face social isolation and rejection because of their moves. typical, the non-financial results of white-collar crimes may be significant and long-lasting. it’s miles essential for people, companies, and authorities’ groups to take steps to prevent and deal with those crimes with a view to shield society as an entire. with the aid of spotting the whole impact of white-collar crimes, it’s miles viable to expand techniques to discourage and discover this sort of crook activity. 

PREVENTION AND DETECTION

Prevention of white-collar crimes can be a terrific task in front of the authorities and society. but sure, measures may be followed to save you them, 

  • Authorities’ campaigns for accelerated attention among trendy public, the more knowledgeable they’re, the lesser they’ll fall into fraudulent scams and traps.
  • Investigating companies must make use of strong rules to modify unlawful flow of cash and profits made with the aid of establishments and groups. 
  • Position of Regulatory corporations- Regulatory businesses play a vital function in detecting and stopping white collar crimes. these businesses, which include the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Securities and exchange Board of India (SEBI) in India, are tasked with overseeing enterprise practices, investigating suspected wrongdoing, and enforcing policies. 
  • Inner Controls and Compliance programs groups themselves have a critical role in preventing white collar crimes through strong internal controls and compliance packages. these may also include stringent financial audits, thorough background checks for employees, regular training applications, and robust ethical hints.
  • Whistleblower safety- Whistleblowers, or people who disclose wrongdoing within an organisation, are frequently instrumental in uncovering white collar crimes. 
  • External Audits- external audits by impartial our bodies can provide an objective evaluation of a organization’s financial statements and operations, assisting to come across any irregularities or signs and symptoms of ability white-collar crime.
  • Using Technology for Detection and Monitoring- In trendy virtual age, generation performs an increasingly more essential function in detecting and stopping white collar crimes. data analytics, artificial intelligence, and device gaining knowledge of can assist examine large volumes of information to identify styles and anomalies that can indicate fraudulent pastime.

INDIAN LEGISLATIVE REGIME: FELONY FRAMEWORK AND PROSECUTION

In India various regulation have been exceeded to be able to combat white collar crime. 

  • Essential Commodities Act, 1955: This act basically offers electricity to the government to problem order for controlling the sale and buy price of important commodities. After many cases of price gouging and hoardings, they introduced mask and sanitisers under the Act. The fee for these items become also constant later. The Ministry of purchasers Affairs advised the kingdom authorities to take measures to preserve the call for and deliver stability of sanitisers. Contravention of the order can lead to imprisonment up to seven years or first-rate. 
  • Industrial (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951: The principle objective of this Act is to take essential steps for the regulation and development of essential industries. The act brings under commerce in sure commodities. This act gives essential method to the significant government to enforce its business coverage. A device of licensing is added below the Act to regulate making plans and destiny development of new assignment on sound lines. 
  • Import and Export (Control) Act, 1947: This Act impose regulations on import and export of products. 
  • Income Tax Act, 1961: This Act become added with the goal of widening the internet of the tax and giving them good sized energy or there was no time limit prescribed beneath the Black cash Act. 
  • Foreign exchange (Regulation) Act, 1973: The FERA Act is a regulation that turned into enacted with the purpose to adjust sure dealing in foreign exchange, impose regulations on certain types of payment and to display the transaction impinging the forex and the import and export of foreign money.
  • Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988: This act focuses to serve a consolidated provision of IPC, CrPC so one can cope with the problems referring to the extended instances of bribery and corruption inside India.
  • Company’s Act, 2013: the availability underneath this act gives a list of sports that falls within the purview of fraud and specific sanction have already been assigned to the equal. furthermore, the character of all of the acts which have been enlisted to be considered as non-cognizable in nature and regulations for speedy path of the equal has also been stated below the Act. 
  • Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002: the primary goal of this Act is limiting any form of activities that got here beneath the ambit of money laundering. As India remains taken into consideration as one of the best hub for the technology of large volumes of black money and thereby variety of sports are being achieved on the attitude of turning the same into prison or actual cash. 
  • Indian Penal Code, 1860: Indian Penal Code incorporate the association to check violation like bank Fraud, insurance Extortion, fee and Misrepresentation and so on. phase 463 to 474 of IPC offers with offence associated with white collar crime and that they encompass defilement and remuneration, nourishment and medicinal drug contaminated, tax avoidance, darkish advertising and marketing, profiteering, storing, tax erosion, human trafficking, virtual incorrect doing and so on. 
  • Information and Technology Act, 2000: This Act is specially enacted to tackle the crime related to computer systems and generation. the principal object of this act is to adjust and authenticate the statistics exchanged even as doing commercial transaction. This Act also include consequences wherein any unauthorized information is downloaded assessed, copied. 
  • Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992: The SEBI is the regulatory enterprise in charge of enacting and amending law governing unfair sports inside the monetary marketplace. This act guarantees that each one crucial information is available to contributors while also ensuring that no sensitive facts is disclosed in system. underneath the stated act, the consequences for doing corrupt interest such as insider buying and selling were mentioned. The Amended Act additionally talks about punishment. 

Those are the numerous acts through which white collar crime can be fight. The principal object of those act is to tackle the crime. This act additionally contains the consequences so that it has a deterrent effect at the wrongdoer of white-collar crime. 

POSITION OF JUDICIARY IN FIGHTING WHITE COLLAR CRIME 

Judiciary has performed an important role in combating white collar crime. now not simplest legislation but also judiciary has an essential function in curbing white collar crime.

  1. SEBI vs Burman Plantation and Others : The organization is being falsely charged, according to the knowledgeable recommendation on behalf of SEBI, since it is no longer able to pay its bills, including investor fees. As the employer’s marketing put the agency in a position to be impeached, the council said that the notice was sent in 2003 and the order was handed down in 2004 when the agency was unable to repay its debt. The sum of money that investors have been claiming has not been specified. The main argument of the recommendation was that the lawmakers should have increased the penalty from one year to ten years and enhanced the exceptional, which may now increase to twenty-five crores by way of amending the legal guidelines beneath Sec 24(1) of SEBI Act. 
  2. Anosh Ekka vs Central Bureau of Investigation  : After becoming a minister, Anosh Ekka amassed a sizable collection of moveable and immovable homes in his and his family’s names over the course of three years, leading to accusations of money laundering. The accused were found guilty of embezzling and misappropriating a substantial sum of Supreme Court public monies. He manipulated the evidence against him and delayed the decision. In addition, he was charged with abusing the court technology and trying to cheat it.
  3. Arun Kumar Mishra vs Directorate of Enforcement : In the aforementioned case, five men and women created a false account with Punjab Countrywide Bank and profited themselves while causing PNB to lose a significant sum of money. The currency laundering case was dropped since this offense was no longer covered by any section of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Legal instructions that are ex-submit facto are not felony-binding. It is a fundamental right under the aforementioned Article to not be tried under laws that were in effect at the time the offense was committed. The court ruled that the Enforcement Directorate may file a fresh case against the petitioner under the applicable statute if evidence of money laundering has been proven against him.

CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS

White collar crimes are the crime which causes a damage to the economy of a country as a whole. It threatens the financial system via Bank Fraud, Monetary Thefts, Evasion of Tax and so forth. It now not handiest affects the economic fame of a country or a person, but it has additionally a poor effect on the society. there’s no proper definition of white-collar crime in Indian legal guidelines. those socio-economic crimes must no longer be taken leniently by using the authorities. There should be extra stringent punishment that allows you to prevent the white-collar crime. the majority aren’t privy to those crimes so there is urgent requirement of public focus with the development of generation the white-collar crime has prolonged at an alarming rate. No era is terrible unless and until we realize the proper key to apply it.

NADEEM

LAW CENTRE-2, FACULTY OF LAW,UNIVERSITY OF DELHI